I usually use both to fire up the boiler and get to a hard rolling boil, then ease back a bit and alternate switching them on as one on its own will normally keep a good boil rolling.
I put it down to the window being open to dissipate the steam and the cold air, so kept both on for most of the 90 min boil. This is what happened to the element backs:

Now the question is are these slip on bits necessary? I've cleaned the melted plastic off the element backs, but do I need to replace these?
Cheers